How to make the Sexy Alligator – Popular at (dance) clubs, including in Denver, Colorado. Sexy Alligator has an amazing taste with a kick that’ll get you in a dancing mood quick! I wouldn’t suggest ordering more than two, they’re strong… and expensive.Pour Midori® Melon Liqueur and Pineapple Juice into a cocktail shaker. Shake and strain into a chilled martini/Cocktail Glass. Add Amaretto by pouring close to the inner edge of the glass; allow to . sink. ” to the bottom. Float Jagermeister® on top; if needed hold spoon to edge of glass while pouring into the spoon. Serve; might not look nIce