How to make the Egg Nog – Cooked – Here’s an Eggnog recipe using cooked Eggs, so no one has to be paranoid about salmonella. Mix Sugar, 2 Tbl. of Water, and Lemon Juice in a med. sized saucepan. Let boil, cook 5 min, until it turns dark amber. Remove from heat, and slowly stir in remaining 1/4 c. of Water. Beat Eggs and Milk together in a bowl. Stir into Sugar Mixture, cook over medium.-low heat for about 10 to 12 minutes. (It should thicken enough to stick to spoon) Poor into a clean bowl (Punch bowl or something), stir in Vanilla, Nutmeg and Salt. Refrigerate, covered, until cold. Before serving, beat together Cream, Liqueur, adn 10x Sugar, until soft peaks form. Pour chilled Eggnog into a serving bowl, fold in Whipped Cream with a whisk.